Couldnt find a thread, although I'm sure there is one and I will be re-directed!

Firstly he was outstanding on Sunday, all be it against inferior opposition (no dis-respect to Cru fans who were fab).

He looks a real talent, but is he out of contract in the summer, and has made nosies that he wants first team play?

With Mcdonnell on already for next year, is there any concern we will lose this fella in the summer, which would be a disgrace and a smack in the mouth for everyone associated to the club.

I may be wrong about all this so apologies if this has been covered already.

It has been mentioned and for me Shaul must be a top priority to keep, natural talent, the main probelm is where he would play next year, if Mcdonnell is fit, he is too old for under 19's. Hopefully he will stay and get a few games at Hull either at FB or as a backup winger to Lineham and Crookes, the other option is to loan him out to another Sl side or Championship team.

There was rumours of him trying his luck in Australia, if he decides this then I cant really blame him, but if we lose him to another SL club, then I will not be happy.

York on a dual reg is not an option as they signed a first choice full back

think w are looking at tieing him up and seding out on loan

Hard call as McDonell has done nothing wrong too

I think if we don't get Shaul tied up to long contract, there we be a lot of disappointed and angry fans, including me. The kid is a real talent and the sort of player we should be signing up for the long term if we are to go to the next level in the future. Just look at Wigan now, they are starting to reap the rewards of bringing their young kids through and we should be doing the same if we are to be successful.

He is indeed out of contract at the end of the season. Not sure if he has been making noises about wanting first team games but Radders commented on it a few weeks ago.

Sunday was the first time I got to see Jamie Shaul in action (I wasn't at the Wakefield game) and he looked outstanding as you said. I certainly hope we get him signed up on a new contract but if he does indeed want first team action then we have a problem on our hands with McDonnell being at the club. He's been a good signing for us so far has McDonnell but I believe Shaul will turn out to be the better player in the long run.

Thats kind of my point too - it may be black and white glasses, but you cant help feel this simply wouldnt happen at Wigan or Leeds, perhaps Saints too?

They consistenly produce young talent that do well, so there must be a model that works, keeps the players happy and part of something but at the same time bringing them in as first choice at the right time?

Perhaps on loan may be the better option, but personally if it came down to choice and we could only have one or the other I think I would realease/sell Mcdonnell and get Shaul into a LTC.

Giant

The problem we have for Jamie, is a problem for all players over 19 and not duel reg.

We have to have quality competition for places, but that would mean some not getting any game time for long periods.

Would it be difficult for a few teams, to start having some sort of unofficial A team friendlies?

Maybe fortnightly mid-week games

Given how AP reacted to Leeds signing Briscoe last year I would be very surprised to see Shaul go to another SL club. I have to say that in sport and business there should be no sentiment and if its a question of a guarantee of regular first team action I would give it to him for the good of the long term future of the club. If that means Shannon is paid off with a year to go on his contract then so be it.

We simply can not afford to lose local talent because we have an Aussie on a contract. He showed enough quality at Wakey to indicate he has the skill and confidence to do well in SL with us and not with any other team thank you.

Can't see that when they still have an option on Billy Slater II.

Are you saying Hudds think he's better than Eden?

I agree that Shaul is a great prospect but does it have to be at fullback ?
Why not convert him back to scrum half - great acceleration off the mark and good hands
Look at Lomax, Tomkins, Hohia who can all play in the halves and fullback