Quote Uncle Rico="Uncle Rico"How is all this stuff decided Charlie? Sorry if I sound thick, but, what is wrong with the current arrangements, everyone seemed to be getting on famously?'"
How Decided ?
I think 'behind closed doors'. There is no formal announcement from the RFL on either the rational ( which i think is mainly money) or how it will operate in practice. Neither has there been an announcement from the Championship clubs, who risk being made into 'feeder clubs'. I would have thought some of the Championship clubs with real SL pretensions might have been against the proposals, particularly with 6 of their team made up from the SL partner. That surely must hinder the development of their own players if they are one of the stronger sides ?
I suspect that there is not a unanimous approval of the proposals.
Why Change ?
As I said, I think money is driving all of this. Some Championship clubs are struggling to find £ for their playing pool, and struggle to raise a viable team when they have a bad run of injuries. To have these players will be a god-send. Similarly, SL clubs like Hull KR are losing money, and can not afford a youth system. I believe Hull KR wish to share a youth system with Hull. However, note that the number of players that you can have registered on your books (max 64 ?) depends on whether you run youth sides, so there is a big incentive for clubs to do so, rather than simply opting out.
Wire position
I understand that both Wire and Saints were against these proposals. You can understand why. Saints have always had a great tradition in youth development, whilst Wire have ploughed a lot of money into the area over the past few years. They can both afford the structure and have high quality coaches and facilities, so why would they wish to change ?
Leigh
Again another guess, but I suspect Wigan may have got in bed with Leigh whilst Wire were prevaricating. However, the arrangement has not been announced yet as far as I know. However Swinton play at LSV so are equally close for players to reach.
Other Issues
Who is going to coach the players ? Will Championship / SL club coaches lose their jobs ?
Strong clubs like Wire, Wigan, Leeds are bound to need more than 6 DR slots at a club, so how is this going to be accommodated ?
What will happen to current 15 & 16 yr teams as they are to be merged into a single 16 team ?
The Championship clubs could gain a great deal from SL clubs know how re marketing, training, sport injuries and possibly even training facilities.
Lots of issues I think.